Wise Response Society calls for immediate fuel rationing as war continues in Middle East

rnz.co.nz·Checkpoint
View original article
0out of 100
Noticeable — persuasion techniques worth noting

This article tries to persuade you that New Zealand's fuel supply is in danger because of the Middle East conflict and that the government needs to start rationing fuel immediately. It uses a sense of urgency and fear to push for this, but doesn't provide key details like current fuel reserves or how likely a supply disruption actually is.

FATE Analysis

Four dimensions of psychological manipulation: how content captures Focus, exploits Authority, triggers Tribal identity, and engineers Emotion.

Focus5/10Authority4/10Tribe2/10Emotion5/10
FFocus
0/10
AAuthority
0/10
TTribe
0/10
EEmotion
0/10

Focus signals

unprecedented framing
"There are calls for fuel rationing following the effective closure of Hormuz Strait as a result of the war in the Middle East which has caused the price of oil to fluctuate."

This frames the situation as immediate and potentially severe, implying an unprecedented need for action like fuel rationing due to external geopolitical events.

attention capture
"rather than waiting for us to hit an issue... it's something that we really should take seriously."

This phrase creates a sense of urgency and direct appeal to the reader's attention, suggesting a critical oversight if not addressed immediately.

novelty spike
"I'd rather be accused of raising the alarm too early and being wrong than staying quiet and being right."

This statement uses a dramatic, self-sacrificing framing to highlight the perceived novelty and importance of the warning, drawing the reader's focus to the 'new' and 'critical' nature of the threat.

Authority signals

institutional authority
"The Wise Response Society has already said the government should activate the National Fuel Security Plan, which was released last November to ensure New Zealand would have reliable access to fuel in case of global or domestic disruption."

The article leverages the existence of a 'National Fuel Security Plan' and its release date to suggest that the proposed actions are not arbitrary but based on pre-existing, official considerations, thus lending weight to the call for activation.

expert appeal
"Chairperson Nathan Surendran told Checkpoint on Wednesday the plan and rationing should be activated as a precaution."

The source is identified as the 'Chairperson' of 'The Wise Response Society' and quoted in a news program ('Checkpoint'), lending him a degree of expert and institutional authority to his calls for action.

institutional authority
"We've got the Petroleum Demand Restraint Act, which gives the government the power to implement rationing by order of the Governor-General."

Referencing a specific piece of legislation ('Petroleum Demand Restraint Act') and the 'Governor-General' provides an air of legitimacy and official backing to the proposed rationing.

Tribe signals

us vs them
"Australia's wholesalers are rationing deliveries to petrol stations, despite that nation having 36 days of reserves and two domestic refineries, New Zealand has neither..."

This sets up a subtle 'us vs. them' dynamic where New Zealand is portrayed as being in a more precarious position compared to Australia, potentially fostering a sense of shared vulnerability or collective concern among New Zealand readers due to a perceived lack of preparation.

Emotion signals

fear engineering
"There are calls for fuel rationing following the effective closure of Hormuz Strait as a result of the war in the Middle East which has caused the price of oil to fluctuate."

This statement immediately introduces a sense of fear and apprehension by linking distant geopolitical conflict to a concrete, critical domestic impact (fuel rationing), which can trigger anxiety about daily life and economic stability.

urgency
"So rather than waiting for us to hit an issue, if we did not receive one of the deliveries that we are supposedly contracted to do... then, yeah, it's something that we really should take seriously."

This engenders a feeling of urgency and potential impending crisis, appealing to anxiety about preparedness and the consequences of inaction.

fear engineering
"The critical question isn't what's here now, it's whether the next round of deliveries will arrive."

This directly targets fear of an uncertain future and potential deprivation, shifting focus away from current availability to a looming threat.

urgency
"I'd rather be accused of raising the alarm too early and being wrong than staying quiet and being right."

This statement uses a dramatic, almost self-sacrificial tone to underscore the perceived gravity and urgency of the situation, aiming to stir emotional conviction rather than purely rational assessment.

Narrative Analysis (PCP)

How the article reshapes thinking: Perception (what beliefs are targeted), Context (what information is shifted or omitted), and Permission (what behavior is being encouraged).

What it wants you to believe

The reader should believe that New Zealand's fuel supply is precarious due to global events, specifically the Middle East conflict, and that immediate, drastic action (like rationing) is necessary to prevent a crisis.

Context being shifted

The article shifts the context from everyday fuel availability to an 'emergency preparedness' mindset, making the idea of rationing feel like a responsible and necessary precaution rather than an extreme measure. It compares New Zealand's situation to Australia's (which has reserves and refineries but is rationing), implying New Zealand's situation is worse and thus requires a similar or stronger response.

What it omits

The article omits details about the actual current fuel reserves in New Zealand, the nature and duration of existing supply contracts beyond a single delivery, the specific trigger thresholds for the National Fuel Security Plan, or the actual daily consumption of fuel versus potential storage capacity. It also doesn't detail the likelihood or specific mechanisms of 'force majeure measures' preventing deliveries.

Desired behavior

The reader is nudged to support or demand government activation of the National Fuel Security Plan and the implementation of fuel rationing. They are encouraged to feel a sense of urgency and concern regarding fuel security.

SMRP Pattern

Four manipulation maintenance tactics: Socializing the idea as normal, Minimizing concerns, Rationalizing with logic, and Projecting blame.

-
Socializing
-
Minimizing
-
Rationalizing
-
Projecting

Red Flags

High-severity indicators: silencing dissent, coordinated messaging, or weaponizing identity to shut down debate.

-
Silencing indicator
!
Controlled release (spokesperson test)

"Chairperson Nathan Surendran told Checkpoint on Wednesday the plan and rationing should be activated as a precaution. 'So rather than waiting for us to hit an issue... it's something that we really should take seriously.' ... 'I'd rather be accused of raising the alarm too early and being wrong than staying quiet and being right.'"

-
Identity weaponization

Techniques Found(2)

Specific propaganda techniques identified using the SemEval-2023 academic taxonomy of 23 techniques across 6 categories.

Appeal to Fear/PrejudiceJustification
"I'd rather be accused of raising the alarm too early and being wrong than staying quiet and being right."

This statement appeals to a sense of fear regarding potential fuel shortages and uses the possibility of being 'right' about a negative outcome as a justification for immediate, precautionary action like rationing.

Appeal to TimeCall
"So rather than waiting for us to hit an issue, if we did not receive one of the deliveries that we are supposedly contracted to do, but which force majeure measures implemented by our suppliers may lead to not arriving, then, yeah, it's something that we really should take seriously."

This quote emphasizes the need for immediate action ('rather than waiting') to address a potential future crisis, creating artificial urgency for the activation of the National Fuel Security Plan and rationing.

Share this analysis