Ukraine: From cyborgs to drone manufacturers

english.elpais.com·Óscar Granados
View original article
0out of 100
Noticeable — persuasion techniques worth noting

This article discusses the rapid growth of military drone production in Ukraine due to Russia's aggression, highlighting how a Ukrainian engineer, Oleksandr Hrachov, switched from soldier to drone manufacturer. It emphasizes Europe's reliance on critical raw materials and lack of skilled personnel as vulnerabilities in this expanding industry, suggesting increased investment and training are necessary for security.

FATE Analysis

Four dimensions of psychological manipulation: how content captures Focus, exploits Authority, triggers Tribal identity, and engineers Emotion.

Focus3/10Authority4/10Tribe6/10Emotion5/10
FFocus
0/10
AAuthority
0/10
TTribe
0/10
EEmotion
0/10

Focus signals

novelty spike
"That’s how the idea of ​​using drones in warfare came about.”That experience was the catalyst for rethinking military technology, paving the way for innovations like drones, now cornerstones of modern industrial capacity."

Presents the origin of drone warfare as a pivotal moment, highlighting its novelty and impact on modern military strategy.

unprecedented framing
"Ukraine has become one of the world’s leading drone producers. According to Bloomberg estimates, the country produces around four million drones annually, compared to the 100,000 manufactured by the U.S. industry, the most powerful in the world."

Highlights Ukraine's unexpected rise as a drone superpower, contrasting it sharply with the U.S. industry, framing it as an extraordinary development.

Authority signals

expert appeal
"Oleksandr Hrachov knows what it’s like to be on a battlefield. When the Russians attacked Crimea in 2014, later annexing it, this Ukrainian engineer volunteered for the army to fight against the separatists at Donetsk Airport in eastern Ukraine. “Yes, I was one of the cyborgs [soldiers known for their fierce resistance against the separatists] and I fought to defend our land,” he says."

Leverages Hrachov's personal military experience and 'cyborg' status to establish his credibility and expertise on military technology and warfare.

institutional authority
"According to Bloomberg estimates, the country produces around four million drones annually, compared to the 100,000 manufactured by the U.S. industry, the most powerful in the world."

Uses Bloomberg's estimates to lend weight and credibility to the statistical claims about drone production.

institutional authority
"Every component, from motors to batteries and sensors, requires specific metals that cannot be substituted without compromising quality. For example, motors use rare earth elements to be powerful and compact, while batteries rely on lithium and cobalt, according to a Rabobank report."

Cites a 'Rabobank report' to back up claims about critical materials, leveraging the perceived expertise of a financial institution on industrial supply chains.

Tribe signals

us vs them
"“When the Russians surrounded us, it was necessary to find a quick solution for aerial reconnaissance. That’s how the idea of ​​using drones in warfare came about.”"

Establishes a clear 'us' (Ukrainians, Hrachov) vs. 'them' (Russians, separatists) dynamic from the start around the conflict and the impetus for technological innovation.

identity weaponization
"“I would have liked to have founded a company that manufactured peace in the world, but the war that came to my home left me no other option. We didn’t choose war. War chose us,” Hrachov says."

Frames the choice to engage in military technology as a survival imperative, linking personal identity to the national struggle and framing it as an unwilling but necessary response.

us vs them
" “Our enemy has people, resources, and money — everything necessary to carry out aggressive policies, aggressive provocations, hybrid warfare, and large-scale combat operations on the territory of another state. Today it is Ukraine. Tomorrow it could be a member of the EU or NATO.”"

Creates a stark 'us vs. them' dynamic, broadly defining 'our enemy' against Ukraine, the EU, and NATO, suggesting a common threat that demands collective action.

Emotion signals

urgency
"“When the Russians surrounded us, it was necessary to find a quick solution for aerial reconnaissance. That’s how the idea of ​​using drones in warfare came about.”"

Conveys a sense of immediate necessity and high stakes, evoking the pressure of being surrounded and the urgency to innovate for survival.

fear engineering
"“I would have liked to have founded a company that manufactured peace in the world, but the war that came to my home left me no other option. We didn’t choose war. War chose us,” Hrachov says."

Evokes a sense of tragedy and existential threat, implying that war is an unavoidable force that dictates choices, potentially eliciting sympathy and fear for victims of aggression.

fear engineering
"“Today we see a continued escalation by Russia, despite all attempts to reach a peace agreement. We observe examples of increasing local aggression in different parts of the world and a general increase in global tension. All of this is driving the development of drones. That’s why, in 2026, 2027, 2028, and beyond, drone production will grow exponentially.”"

Generates anxiety and fear by highlighting 'continued escalation by Russia,' 'increasing local aggression,' and 'general increase in global tension,' predicting a future of exponential drone growth driven by conflict.

urgency
"The main problem is that most of these resources are located outside the European Union, limiting its ability to make independent defense decisions. “China controls between 70% and 90% of the rare earth market needed for battery materials. This creates a serious dependency in defense and drone manufacturing supply chains worldwide,” says Hrachov."

Highlights a 'serious dependency' and limitation on 'independent defense decisions,' creating a sense of vulnerability and urgency for the EU to address resource acquisition.

fear engineering
"“Our enemy has people, resources, and money — everything necessary to carry out aggressive policies, aggressive provocations, hybrid warfare, and large-scale combat operations on the territory of another state. Today it is Ukraine. Tomorrow it could be a member of the EU or NATO.”"

Directly engineers fear by projecting the threat of aggression from Ukraine to EU and NATO members, creating a sense of impending danger and shared vulnerability.

Narrative Analysis (PCP)

How the article reshapes thinking: Perception (what beliefs are targeted), Context (what information is shifted or omitted), and Permission (what behavior is being encouraged).

What it wants you to believe

The article aims to instill the belief that military drone production, particularly in Ukraine, is a necessary and rapidly expanding industry driven by global security threats, primarily from Russia. It also tries to establish that European reliance on external sources for critical raw materials and lack of sufficient human resources for drone technology pose significant vulnerabilities.

Context being shifted

The article shifts context by repeatedly citing Russian aggression as the sole and unavoidable catalyst for the growth of the drone industry and the urgency of addressing supply chain and human resource issues. This framing makes the accelerated production and reliance on drone warfare appear as a rational and defensive measure.

What it omits

The article omits deeper geopolitical context regarding the origins and complexities of the conflict in Ukraine beyond 'Russian aggression,' which might provide alternative perspectives on the 'unavoidable' nature of this arms race. It also does not delve into potential ethical concerns or long-term societal impacts of widespread military drone development, focusing exclusively on the perceived need for these technologies for defense.

Desired behavior

The article subtly nudges the reader towards accepting and supporting increased investment in military drone technology, addressing critical material dependencies, and training specialists in unmanned systems, viewing these as essential steps for European and global security against perceived threats.

SMRP Pattern

Four manipulation maintenance tactics: Socializing the idea as normal, Minimizing concerns, Rationalizing with logic, and Projecting blame.

-
Socializing
-
Minimizing
!
Rationalizing

"“I would have liked to have founded a company that manufactured peace in the world, but the war that came to my home left me no other option. We didn’t choose war. War chose us,” Hrachov says."

-
Projecting

Red Flags

High-severity indicators: silencing dissent, coordinated messaging, or weaponizing identity to shut down debate.

-
Silencing indicator
!
Controlled release (spokesperson test)

"“Today we see a continued escalation by Russia, despite all attempts to reach a peace agreement. We observe examples of increasing local aggression in different parts of the world and a general increase in global tension. All of this is driving the development of drones. That’s why, in 2026, 2027, 2028, and beyond, drone production will grow exponentially.”"

-
Identity weaponization

Techniques Found(4)

Specific propaganda techniques identified using the SemEval-2023 academic taxonomy of 23 techniques across 6 categories.

Appeal to ValuesJustification
"“Yes, I was one of the cyborgs [soldiers known for their fierce resistance against the separatists] and I fought to defend our land,” he says."

The speaker invokes the value of defending one's homeland, leveraging national pride and the concept of 'our land' to justify his past actions and, by extension, the current military efforts.

Appeal to ValuesJustification
"“I would have liked to have founded a company that manufactured peace in the world, but the war that came to my home left me no other option. We didn’t choose war. War chose us,” Hrachov says."

Hrachov appeals to universal values of peace and self-preservation, portraying the engagement in military technology as a regrettable but forced necessity. This frames the conflict as an unavoidable imposition, garnering sympathy and justification for their actions.

Appeal to Fear/PrejudiceJustification
"“Our enemy has people, resources, and money — everything necessary to carry out aggressive policies, aggressive provocations, hybrid warfare, and large-scale combat operations on the territory of another state. Today it is Ukraine. Tomorrow it could be a member of the EU or NATO.”"

This quote uses fear to persuade by suggesting that the 'enemy' poses an imminent and escalating threat not just to Ukraine, but potentially to EU and NATO members. It aims to instill anxiety about future aggression to justify present actions and calls for investment in defense.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
"“Our enemy has people, resources, and money — everything necessary to carry out aggressive policies, aggressive provocations, hybrid warfare, and large-scale combat operations on the territory of another state. Today it is Ukraine. Tomorrow it could be a member of the EU or NATO.”"

The words 'aggressive policies,' 'aggressive provocations,' and 'hybrid warfare' are emotionally charged and disproportionately describe the opponent's actions as inherently hostile and expansive, aiming to create a negative impression without specific, detailed evidence in the immediate context beyond the general assertion.

Share this analysis