There is war in our backyard and we have forgotten all about it

smh.com.au·Michael Ruffles
View original article
0out of 100
Noticeable — persuasion techniques worth noting

This article aims to convince you that the Myanmar junta is brutal and causing immense suffering, while portraying the resistance as a hopeful, principled force. It uses emotionally charged language, like calling Sean Turnell's charges 'spurious' and highlighting the 'catastrophe' of the economy, and frames the situation as a stark 'us-vs-them' conflict between the junta and the populace. The article supports its claims by quoting individuals like economist Sean Turnell and aid worker San May Thu, and referencing UN estimates for displacement and casualties to underscore the severity of the crisis.

FATE Analysis

Four dimensions of psychological manipulation: how content captures Focus, exploits Authority, triggers Tribal identity, and engineers Emotion.

Focus3/10Authority4/10Tribe5/10Emotion6/10
FFocus
0/10
AAuthority
0/10
TTribe
0/10
EEmotion
0/10

Focus signals

attention capture
"As everyone was absorbing the Reserve Bank’s decision to raise interest rates on Tuesday evening, one economist received something of a rock-star reception."

This establishes a contrast with a widely-discussed national event to highlight the 'rock-star reception' of the economist, suggesting something noteworthy and extraordinary is happening beyond the common news cycle.

unprecedented framing
"A conflict in our backyard that has been forgotten."

This attempts to reframe a distant conflict as 'in our backyard' and 'forgotten,' suggesting a novel and urgent perspective that readers should now pay attention to.

Authority signals

expert appeal
"Sean Turnell, the former senior economic advisor to deposed Myanmar leader Aung San Suu Kyi and one-time jailbird on spurious espionage charges, was in demand in Sydney’s inner west for photographs and autographs in his prison memoirs."

Leverages Turnell's past role as a senior economic advisor to a significant political figure and his experience as a 'jailbird on spurious espionage charges' to establish his credibility and unique insight into the situation.

expert appeal
"“I guess it’s just a catastrophe,” Turnell told a full house at Tuesday night’s panel discussion and documentary screening at Leichhardt Town Hall."

Presents Turnell's strong assessment as an expert, using his direct quote from a public event to add weight to the economic claims.

expert appeal
"For San May Thu, from the Humanitarian Advisory Group, the greatest challenge is ensuring food can reach people, bypassing a regime that has “restricted and blocked and weaponised” aid."

Quotes an individual from a humanitarian organization to lend authority and credibility to claims about aid obstruction, using their title and affiliation.

expert appeal
"Noor, the 2024 NSW Young Woman of the Year"

Highlights a recent award to bolster the credibility and standing of the individual making claims about discrimination and trauma, adding an extra layer of perceived authority.

Tribe signals

us vs them
"the coup that tore Myanmar asunder, when Min Aung Hlaing’s junta ousted a fledgling if flawed democracy and plunged the country into a protracted and deadly civil war."

Establishes a clear division between the 'junta' and 'fledgling democracy,' framing the conflict as a struggle against an oppressive force, creating an 'us' (democracy supporters) and 'them' (the junta) dynamic.

us vs them
"The community have become the frontline responders,” May said, adding it has been “five years not just of a worsening situation but increasing reliance on the grassroots” for survival."

Divides the actors into 'community/grassroots' as the victims and frontline responders, and implicitly the 'regime' as the oppressors, fostering an emotional connection with the 'community' side.

identity weaponization
"Noor Azizah, a refugee and co-founder of the Rohingya Maìyafuìnor Collaborative Network, was more explicit in calling out China’s support for the Myanmar military. She highlighted the oil and gas pipelines built during the Rohingya genocide, which began years before the coup, when agrarian “ancestral knowledge was wiped out”."

Weaponizes the identity of 'refugee' and 'Rohingya' to add moral weight to the claims against China and the Myanmar military, linking the exploitation to the loss of 'ancestral knowledge' of a specific group.

us vs them
"while there had been fundraising events every Saturday in Sydney for five years, at times the efforts overlapped or proved counterproductive. “We are not going to overthrow the government from the front line of Sydney,” he smiled. “We have a role. It’s not small. We have to focus on what we want to do.”"

Implies a 'we' (the diaspora actively working for change) against the 'government' (the junta), and implicitly against external forces that might be disrupting their efforts, although the 'we' is also cautioned about internal divisions.

Emotion signals

outrage manufacturing
"Junta leader senior general Min Aung Hlaing attends a ceremony to commission new aircraft into the Myanmar air force in March.APIt has killed thousands, although given the country has returned to an information black hole the true toll is inexact. The UN estimates 5.2 million people have been displaced, both internally and across the borders, while food insecurity is acute and military airstrikes hit civilian populations and infrastructure. The coup only exacerbated a refugee crisis and allowed the Myanmar military’s genocide of the Rohingya to continue unchecked."

This passage directly connects the junta leader to actions (commissioning aircraft) while immediately listing widespread suffering and atrocities: 'killed thousands,' 'information black hole,' '5.2 million people displaced,' 'food insecurity is acute,' 'military airstrikes hit civilian populations,' 'refugee crisis,' and 'genocide of the Rohingya to continue unchecked.' The accumulation of these devastating facts is intended to evoke strong outrage and moral condemnation against the regime.

fear engineering
"Then there is the economy. “I guess it’s just a catastrophe,” Turnell told a full house at Tuesday night’s panel discussion and documentary screening at Leichhardt Town Hall."

The term 'catastrophe' used by an expert is designed to evoke fear regarding the economic situation, suggesting a dire and potentially irreparable state of affairs.

outrage manufacturing
"For San May Thu, from the Humanitarian Advisory Group, the greatest challenge is ensuring food can reach people, bypassing a regime that has “restricted and blocked and weaponised” aid."

The accusation that the regime 'restricted and blocked and weaponised' aid is a powerful charge designed to generate outrage at the perceived cruelty and moral reprehensibility of the junta, particularly concerning basic human needs.

moral superiority
"“A lot of people in Australia say it doesn’t get the coverage it deserves,” she said, later adding: “This is in the backyard of Sydney.”"

This quote creates a sense of moral urgency and implicit guilt, suggesting that the reader (and wider Australian public) should care more about this issue because it's 'in the backyard of Sydney' and is not receiving adequate attention, positioning the concern as a morally superior stance.

Narrative Analysis (PCP)

How the article reshapes thinking: Perception (what beliefs are targeted), Context (what information is shifted or omitted), and Permission (what behavior is being encouraged).

What it wants you to believe

The article aims to instill a belief that the Myanmar junta is oppressive, economically destructive, and a cause of widespread suffering, while painting the resistance and exiled figures as credible, principled, and ultimately hopeful for a better future. It also intends to create a sense of global responsibility and local relevance regarding the conflict.

Context being shifted

The article shifts context by presenting the testimonies of an economist jailed by the junta, a human rights worker, and refugees discussing local aid efforts and international interests. This makes the conflict feel more immediate, personal, and universally condemnable, moving it from a geopolitical abstraction to a human tragedy with clear villains and victims.

What it omits

The article omits deeper historical context of ethnic tensions, the complexities of Aung San Suu Kyi's previous governance regarding certain ethnic groups (e.g., Rohingya crisis pre-coup), and the nuanced geopolitical motivations of international actors beyond simple 'support for the regime.' This omission simplifies the narrative to a good vs. evil dichotomy more conducive to its persuasion goals.

Desired behavior

The article implicitly grants permission for readers to feel sympathy and solidarity with the victims and opposition to the Myanmar junta, to view international involvement (especially by China and Russia) critically, and to believe in the possibility of positive change through sustained pressure and unity. It encourages a stance of advocacy for human rights and democratic restoration in Myanmar.

SMRP Pattern

Four manipulation maintenance tactics: Socializing the idea as normal, Minimizing concerns, Rationalizing with logic, and Projecting blame.

-
Socializing
-
Minimizing
-
Rationalizing
-
Projecting

Red Flags

High-severity indicators: silencing dissent, coordinated messaging, or weaponizing identity to shut down debate.

-
Silencing indicator
-
Controlled release (spokesperson test)
-
Identity weaponization

Techniques Found(7)

Specific propaganda techniques identified using the SemEval-2023 academic taxonomy of 23 techniques across 6 categories.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
"fledgling if flawed democracy"

The term 'fledgling if flawed democracy' uses emotionally charged language to implicitly criticize the pre-coup government while still casting it in a somewhat positive light against the current regime, influencing reader perception.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
"plunged the country into a protracted and deadly civil war"

The words 'plunged,' 'protracted,' and 'deadly' are emotionally charged and designed to evoke strong negative feelings about the coup and the subsequent conflict.

Exaggeration/MinimisationManipulative Wording
"A conflict in our backyard that has been forgotten."

This statement exaggerates the notion that the conflict is universally 'forgotten' by portraying it as an overlooked crisis close to home, aiming to elicit a sense of urgency and concern from the reader.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
"information black hole"

This phrase is emotionally charged, depicting a dire and opaque situation regarding information access, which intensifies the perception of the conflict's severity.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
"regime that has “restricted and blocked and weaponised” aid"

The verbs 'restricted,' 'blocked,' and especially 'weaponised' are highly charged, presenting the junta's actions in an extremely negative and morally reprehensible light.

Obfuscation/VaguenessManipulative Wording
"agrarian “ancestral knowledge was wiped out”"

The phrase 'ancestral knowledge was wiped out,' while evoking sympathy, is vague about the specific mechanisms or full extent of this 'wiping out,' making it harder to precisely quantify or dispute.

Exaggeration/MinimisationManipulative Wording
"“This is in the backyard of Sydney.”"

This statement exaggerates the geographical proximity and immediate relevance of the Myanmar conflict to Sydney, aiming to make it feel more urgent and personal to Australian readers.

Share this analysis