Evelyn Araluen wins $125,000 for ‘politically uncompromising’ poetry at Victorian premier’s literary awards

theguardian.com·Sian Cain
View original article
0out of 100
Noticeable — persuasion techniques worth noting

This article uses emotional language and emphasizes expert opinions to portray Evelyn Araluen's work as a crucial, courageous commentary on current events, especially regarding the Israel-Gaza conflict. It also highlights the financial struggles of artists to advocate for fairer tax laws, but it leaves out details about the heckling incident Araluen faced and specific comparisons of tax laws in other countries.

FATE Analysis

Four dimensions of psychological manipulation: how content captures Focus, exploits Authority, triggers Tribal identity, and engineers Emotion.

Focus3/10Authority4/10Tribe3/10Emotion6/10
FFocus
0/10
AAuthority
0/10
TTribe
0/10
EEmotion
0/10

Focus signals

novelty spike
"Evelyn Araluen has won both the $100,000 Victorian prize for literature and the $25,000 Indigenous writing category at this year’s Victorian premier’s literary awards, for her second poetry collection The Rot."

This highlights a significant, recent achievement, using the monetary value of the prize and the 'this year's' framing to capture immediate attention with a sense of newness and accomplishment.

unprecedented framing
"Selected from almost 700 books entered for the prize, The Rot won the two awards on Thursday night, having also been shortlisted in the poetry category."

The mention of 'almost 700 books' emphasizes the rarity and magnitude of winning, suggesting an extraordinary event that demands attention due to its exceptional nature.

breaking framing
"Speaking before she was aware she had also won the overall prize, Araluen told Guardian Australia she was “excited” to have won the $25,000 Indigenous writing category."

The 'before she was aware' phrasing creates a sense of immediacy and draws the reader into the unfolding news, making it feel like they are getting the story as it develops.

Authority signals

institutional authority
"Evelyn Araluen has won both the $100,000 Victorian prize for literature and the $25,000 Indigenous writing category at this year’s Victorian premier’s literary awards, for her second poetry collection The Rot."

The 'Victorian prize for literature' and 'Victorian premier’s literary awards' are institutions lending significant weight and credibility to Araluen's work, implying it is of high quality as judged by established bodies.

expert appeal
"The judges called The Rot “a work of remarkable poetic intelligence; formally bold, emotionally exacting and politically uncompromising” and “a vital intervention in this country’s cultural conversation.”"

The opinion of 'the judges' (unnamed experts in literature) is used to endorse the book's quality and significance, influencing reader perception through expert validation.

institutional authority
"The Goorie and Koori poet won the 2022 Stella prize, and was shortlisted for three premier’s literary prizes, for her debut collection Dropbear."

Winning the 'Stella prize' and being 'shortlisted for three premier’s literary prizes' are institutional recognitions that establish her as a highly esteemed author, leveraging the legitimacy of these awards.

Tribe signals

us vs them
"“These poems were about witnessing a genocide and the feeling of inertia and grief and rage and passivity that sits in the body when you feel so powerless against our government’s complicity in that genocide,” Araluen said."

This quote creates an 'us vs. them' dynamic between individuals who feel powerless and the 'government’s complicity,' framing a collective emotional state against a perceived antagonist.

social outcasting
"“I had people get up and leave and shout at me and have a go at me … I shouted back and felt so enraged.”"

This describes a public confrontation where the author faced vocal opposition and felt enraged, highlighting a social division created by the content of her work, and showing potential for social discomfort or outcasting for differing views.

manufactured consensus
"“But I had incredibly beautiful people coming up to me afterwards, some of them crying, saying the poems had helped them understand how they have been feeling.”"

This portrays a solidarity among a group who resonated deeply with her work, implying a shared sentiment and validating her perspective by showing a strong, emotional, collective agreement (creating a 'these people understand' dynamic).

Emotion signals

outrage manufacturing
"“These poems were about witnessing a genocide and the feeling of inertia and grief and rage and passivity that sits in the body when you feel so powerless against our government’s complicity in that genocide,” Araluen said."

The words 'genocide,' 'grief,' 'rage,' 'powerless,' and 'complicity' are highly emotionally charged, designed to evoke outrage and sadness in the reader regarding global events and governmental actions.

emotional fractionation
"“But I had incredibly beautiful people coming up to me afterwards, some of them crying, saying the poems had helped them understand how they have been feeling.”"

This shifts from the negative emotions of 'rage' and 'powerlessness' (mentioned earlier) to a sense of solidarity, validation, and emotional connection, creating a fluctuation between despair and comfort/understanding.

moral superiority
"“I tried to make sure that the book very clearly documented that we knew what was happening in our names and we did not stop it,” she added. “I hope that this book dates. I hope it reads as incredibly naive and doesn’t catch a glimpse of the political ambitions that are going to be realised in the future. But if it doesn’t, I want it to be a record of a very, very uncomfortable truth that we’re all going to have to live with.”"

This passage positions the author as someone documenting an 'uncomfortable truth' that 'we all knew' but 'did not stop,' implicitly appealing to the reader's sense of moral responsibility and potentially inducing guilt or a desire to align with the 'truth-teller' viewpoint.

outrage manufacturing
"“Winning the Stella prize was really fantastic but it was taxed at nearly 50%,” she said. “When you spend sometimes years of your life working on something, and you have good fortune that you can’t have possibly planned for or anticipated, the impact of a prize can sometimes be quite disruptive financially.”"

The statement about 'nearly 50%' taxation on a prize, after 'years of your life working on something,' is designed to provoke a sense of unfairness or outrage about the financial impact on artists, appealing to a sense of injustice.

Narrative Analysis (PCP)

How the article reshapes thinking: Perception (what beliefs are targeted), Context (what information is shifted or omitted), and Permission (what behavior is being encouraged).

What it wants you to believe

The article aims to instill the belief that Evelyn Araluen's work, particularly 'The Rot,' is not only deserving of literary accolades but also represents a vital and courageous voice speaking an 'uncomfortable truth' about current events, specifically the conflict in Gaza. It further targets the belief that artists, especially those from marginalized backgrounds, are often financially vulnerable despite their success and that the current tax system for prizes is unjust.

Context being shifted

The article shifts the context of a literary award announcement from a celebration of artistic achievement to a platform for political commentary and a critique of governmental policies (both on international conflict and arts taxation). It frames the author's personal experience of being heckled for her views as evidence of her powerful and necessary voice, making her political stance integral to her artistic merit.

What it omits

The article omits detailed context regarding the specific nature of the heckling incident Araluen faced at Adelaide writers’ week, such as the exact statements made by hecklers or the broader discussion surrounding the event, which could provide alternative perspectives on the incident. It also does not delve into the nuances of taxation laws for literary prizes in other countries, or the specific criteria for tax exemptions, beyond a general statement that 'other countries have really intelligent taxation laws.'

Desired behavior

The article subtly nudges readers to view artists who use their platforms for political commentary as brave and necessary voices. It encourages empathy for artists' financial struggles and suggests that current tax policies are unfair to them. It also may implicitly grant permission for a critical stance towards the Australian government's perceived complicity in international conflicts and its arts policies.

SMRP Pattern

Four manipulation maintenance tactics: Socializing the idea as normal, Minimizing concerns, Rationalizing with logic, and Projecting blame.

-
Socializing
-
Minimizing
-
Rationalizing
!
Projecting

"“These poems were about witnessing a genocide and the feeling of inertia and grief and rage and passivity that sits in the body when you feel so powerless against our government’s complicity in that genocide”"

Red Flags

High-severity indicators: silencing dissent, coordinated messaging, or weaponizing identity to shut down debate.

-
Silencing indicator
-
Controlled release (spokesperson test)
-
Identity weaponization

Techniques Found(7)

Specific propaganda techniques identified using the SemEval-2023 academic taxonomy of 23 techniques across 6 categories.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
""a vital intervention in this country’s cultural conversation.""

This phrase uses emotionally charged and positive language ('vital intervention') to amplify the significance and positive impact of the work, portraying it as essential and impactful within the cultural discourse.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
""These poems were about witnessing a genocide and the feeling of inertia and grief and rage and passivity that sits in the body when you feel so powerless against our government’s complicity in that genocide,""

The words 'genocide', 'inertia', 'grief', 'rage', 'passivity', and 'powerless' are highly emotional and evoke strong negative feelings, aiming to elicit a specific emotional response from the reader about the political situation being described.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
""But I had incredibly beautiful people coming up to me afterwards, some of them crying, saying the poems had helped them understand how they have been feeling.""

The phrases 'incredibly beautiful people' and 'some of them crying' use emotionally charged language to create a positive and empathetic image of support and emotional impact, validating the writer's work and perspective.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
""a really panicked, distressed window of a time, that I hope we all look back on with horror and despair and a real sense of regret,""

The words 'panicked', 'distressed', 'horror', 'despair', and 'regret' are strong negative emotion-laden terms used to convey the gravity and negative emotional impact of the subject matter, encouraging the reader to share this sentiment.

Exaggeration/MinimisationManipulative Wording
""Winning the Stella prize was really fantastic but it was taxed at nearly 50%,""

Stating 'nearly 50%' taxation might be an accurate figure in specific marginal brackets, but in this context, it is presented as a high, impactful percentage to highlight the perceived unfairness of the tax system on artists, potentially exaggerating the general impact on her overall earnings.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
""Other countries have really intelligent taxation laws that allow artists to continue working in periods of heightened prosperity versus significantly lower incomes.""

The phrase 'really intelligent taxation laws' uses positive loaded language to praise certain foreign tax systems, implicitly criticizing the Australian system as less intelligent or effective without providing specific details or comparative analysis, framing desirable policy as a matter of 'intelligence'.

Loaded LanguageManipulative Wording
""controversially dumped from this year’s Adelaide writers’ week, a decision that triggered the collapse of the annual literary event.""

The phrase 'controversially dumped' uses emotionally charged language to highlight the negative and disputed nature of the decision. 'Triggered the collapse' further uses strong, dramatic language to emphasize the severe consequence of that action.

Share this analysis