Questioning the Reputation

Attacking the character of the person making an argument instead of the argument.

What we have recorded

Instances recorded156
Articles containing it139
Share of all recorded techniques0.3%
Average manipulation score where present54.4 (corpus average 45.1)

Outlets where we have recorded it most

Counts reflect the articles we have analyzed, which are not a representative sample of any outlet's output.

Recent examples

israelnationalnews.com
"the man who disgraced America when he surrendered to the Taliban in Afghanistan"

Attacks Joe Biden’s character and competence by using a contested interpretation of the Afghanistan withdrawal, undermining his credibility on Middle East policy without engaging with his actual statements or rationale.

Before Iran has its nuclear bomb, Israel must destroy the ayatollahs
presstv.co.uk
"Does he belong at this podium to justify his crimes, or in the dock of a court of law to answer for genocide?"

Directly challenges Netanyahu’s legitimacy and moral standing by asserting he should be on trial, thereby attacking his personal and political reputation rather than engaging solely with policy or argument.

Iran condemns Netanyahu’s UN speech, says Israel using world body to justify Gaza genocide
presstv.co.uk
"President Trump has blamed the rise in oil prices on the legacy of the Biden administration, insisting that prices will 'drop like a rock' once the military conflict with Iran comes to an end"

Presents Trump's statement in a context that implicitly questions his credibility by juxtaposing his optimistic claim with ongoing record diesel prices and market concerns, inviting skepticism about his judgment without directly refuting with evidence.

Global economy suffers Hormuz closure
cnn.com
"the population does 'not have a legitimate right to self-determination' and that any argument based on a referendum held there 'is invalid.'"

Attacks the legitimacy and moral standing of the Falkland Islanders by dismissing their right to self-determination, undermining their political agency without engaging with the legal basis of their position.

Argentina ratchets up Falklands tensions after Trump casts doubt on support for Britain | CNN
middleeasteye.net
"the journalists who work for these outlets would tell you that they are being fair and balanced... But the opposite is true."

Directly attacks the character and professional ethics of journalists in western media, asserting bad faith or inaccuracy without engaging with their editorial processes or sourcing, thereby undermining their authority.

Israel is not 'testing' its ceasefires. It's violating them
breitbart.com
"their reporters do not have the authority to describe the damage caused by migration to ordinary Americans."

This statement attacks the credibility and legitimacy of reporters without addressing the substance of their work, implying they are either unqualified or structurally prevented from telling the 'truth.' It undermines the professionalism of journalists rather than engaging with their reporting, constituting Questioning the Reputation.

White House Shows How Trump's Migration Reforms Cut Housing Costs
kyivpost.com
"a massive drone attack on our region was organized by the criminal regime of the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU)."

Labels Ukraine’s military as a 'criminal regime' to discredit its legitimacy and actions, attacking its character rather than engaging with the military objective or context of the strike.

Mass Drone Raid Hits Orenburg Gas Giant 1,500 km From Ukraine, Russia’s Only Helium Plant Ablaze
euronews.com
"“The main thing is for the Russian people to begin to realise that it is just one man, Putin, who is waging this war, whilst it is the people who are paying the price for everything.”"

Zelenskyy attributes sole responsibility for the war to Putin, directly undermining his legitimacy and moral standing, thereby attacking his character rather than engaging with potential complexities in decision-making or domestic political structures.

‘If Ukraine burns, so will Moscow,’ Zelenskyy says after refinery fire

Other Attack on Reputation techniques

Check an article for questioning the reputation and 22 other techniques.

Analyze a URL