Whataboutism
Answering criticism by pointing at someone else's wrongdoing rather than addressing the criticism.
What we have recorded
| Instances recorded | 419 |
|---|---|
| Articles containing it | 409 |
| Share of all recorded techniques | 0.7% |
| Average manipulation score where present | 55.2 (corpus average 45.1) |
Outlets where we have recorded it most
| Outlet | Instances recorded |
|---|---|
| rt.com | 74 |
| aljazeera.com | 32 |
| breitbart.com | 31 |
| dailywire.com | 23 |
| nbcnews.com | 22 |
Counts reflect the articles we have analyzed, which are not a representative sample of any outlet's output.
Recent examples
"China has repeatedly made its position clear: it opposes attempts by certain countries to politicize economic and trade issues and pursue trade protectionism under the pretext of so-called overcapacity"
Rather than addressing the specific claims about industrial overcapacity, the statement shifts focus to the alleged protectionism and politicization by 'certain countries,' thereby deflecting from the core issue by accusing others of improper motives, which serves to divert attention from the substance of the overcapacity debate.
China opposes trade protectionism, vows firm response to measures harming its interests: MOFCOM on US-led ‘overcapacity’ narrative and curbs"If the President wants to actually bring down energy prices, he can do it by solving the Iran problem, not by doing a solid for Vladimir Putin"
Sen. Tillis deflects from the issue of waiving Russia sanctions by shifting focus to the 'Iran problem' as an alternative solution to high energy prices. This introduces a separate geopolitical issue to divert attention from the consequences of the current decision, functioning as a distraction rather than a direct rebuttal.
Zelenskyy says Trump is ‘rewarding Putin’ as he waives new Russia sanctions passed by Congress"US officials’ propaganda and repeated claims of controlling the Strait of Hormuz would not change realities on the ground"
Deflects from the focus on Iran's actions by shifting attention to alleged U.S. propaganda, implying that American statements invalidate their position or justify Iranian countermeasures, rather than addressing the substance of maritime access or tanker incidents directly.
Iranian Army says violating oil tanker catches fire near Strait of Hormuz"The president renewed his calls to expel Omar in February after she interrupted his State of the Union address to protest his immigration crackdown."
Shifts focus from the substance of Omar’s protest and the raid to her conduct during the speech, using her behavior as a justification to deflect from potential abuse of power in targeting her.
Feds Raid Home of Trump Nemesis He Wants Thrown in Jail"Trump has sought to blame the Ukraine conflict, rather than his own assault on Iran, for a global fuel shortage that has driven diesel prices to record highs since the U.S. launched the Middle East war in February."
Shifts focus from Trump’s role in causing fuel shortages through military action by redirecting blame to the Ukraine conflict, thereby deflecting responsibility with a comparative wrongdoing.
Trump claims ‘energy ceasefire,’ but Ukraine says Russia keeps striking its energy facilities"This dangerous attempt to evade arrest comes after sanctuary politicians held webinars and provided resources and tips for how to openly defy ICE"
Shifts focus from the conduct of the individual suspect to the unrelated actions of politicians, implying that criticism of ICE tactics or provision of legal advice justifies evasion of arrest. This deflects scrutiny of enforcement methods by blaming third parties.
Illegal Alien Injured in Texas After Fleeing ICE Officers with Previously Deported Criminal"Yet they have no history or civilization to be proud of, because civilization belongs to the East and the Muslim world"
Deflects from the substance of U.S. and Israeli positions by shifting focus to alleged Western historical crimes, redirecting attention to past injustices rather than addressing current geopolitical claims or actions.
US and Israel lack civilization, seek to plunder Eastern wealth: IRGC advisor"escalating tensions would benefit only the Israeli regime"
Shifts focus from Iran's own regional actions or policies by redirecting attention to Israel's alleged beneficiary position, implying that criticism of Iran should be dismissed because another actor (Israel) gains from the conflict, rather than addressing the substance of the tensions directly.
Iran: Hormuz security cannot return to normal amid US blockade, economic warOther Distraction techniques
Check an article for whataboutism and 22 other techniques.
Analyze a URL