Whataboutism

Answering criticism by pointing at someone else's wrongdoing rather than addressing the criticism.

What we have recorded

Instances recorded310
Articles containing it303
Share of all recorded techniques0.7%
Average manipulation score where present55.5 (corpus average 45.9)

Outlets where we have recorded it most

Counts reflect the articles we have analyzed, which are not a representative sample of any outlet's output.

Recent examples

globaltimes.cn
"Earlier, the US and Japan joined the Philippines in maritime exercises in the South China Sea in five-day drills from Jul 21 to 25, and in May, the Philippines and the US conducted the Balikatan exercise."

Introduces prior military activities by the Philippines and its allies not to provide context but to deflect from the nature of China’s current drills, implying equivalence or greater culpability elsewhere to justify or downplay China’s own military posturing.

Exclusive: Type 071 amphibious transport dock, H-6K bombers involved in PLA’s drills around Huangyan Dao; move aimed at countering series of Philippine activities: experts
middleeasteye.net
"But who did Israel agree the ceasefire with? Yes, Hamas."

Shifts focus from the alleged ceasefire violations by Israel to the identity of the party with which the ceasefire was made, implying that targeting members of Hamas—even without evidence—undermines the need to call out violations, thus deflecting from the core issue of compliance.

Israel is not 'testing' its ceasefires. It's violating them
breitbart.com
"The CCP does not allow U.S. telecom companies into China"

Deflects from the issue of Chinese firms operating in the U.S. by pointing to reciprocal exclusion in China, shifting focus to perceived unfairness rather than addressing the specific security claims at hand.

Congress Warns China ‘Deeply Embedded in the U.S. Internet Ecosystem’
foxnews.com
"White House blasts Spanish government as thousands of migrants surge from Morocco, emergency request denied"

The headline introduces a political counter-accusation (White House criticism of Spain) that shifts focus from the situation in Ceuta and Morocco’s role to U.S. domestic political blame. This deflects scrutiny from broader systemic factors by redirecting attention to intergovernmental disputes, without engaging with root causes or humanitarian dimensions.

Ceuta migrant surge exposes Spain-Morocco tensions as Islamist groups reportedly seek to exploit border crisis
aljazeera.com
"We must all be vigilant against Israeli plots and false-flag operations designed to undermine regional peace."

Diverts attention from Iran's own regional attacks by shifting focus to alleged Israeli deception and provocations. This deflects accountability by introducing an unrelated accusation (Israeli false-flag operations) in response to scrutiny over Iranian actions in Egypt.

IRGC strikes US targets in Kuwait a day after US hits Iran: Latest events
cbsnews.com
"Trump knows exactly who is responsible for this attack, and knows that other states were hit too."

Governor Walz’s statement shifts focus from the cyberattack itself to the Trump administration’s prior actions, implying that criticism of Minnesota is hypocritical given broader federal failures. This deflects from the immediate issue by pointing to unrelated past behavior, constituting a whataboutism.

U.S. investigating if Iran was behind cyberattack on water systems in 7 states, including Minnesota
cnn.com
"Like Fauci, Smith has come under extended scrutiny from Trump allies, who were angered by his investigation into Trump’s efforts to overturn the 2020 election."

This comparison shifts focus from the merits of the current hearing to past political conflicts involving Jack Smith, implying moral equivalence and deflecting criticism of Republican actions by pointing to Democratic-led investigations—thereby diverting attention from the immediate issue at hand.

Dr. Anthony Fauci repeatedly invokes the Fifth in dramatic Senate hearing about Covid pandemic | CNN Politics
npr.org
"it's oversight."

This response by Paul, positioned as a rebuttal to Fauci’s characterization of the inquiry as a 'waste of time,' deflects criticism by re-labeling the same activity as legitimate oversight. It shifts focus from the substance of the allegations or the validity of the investigation to a debate over procedural legitimacy, serving to sidestep engagement with Fauci’s expressed frustration.

Rand Paul releases Anthony Fauci's pandemic-era diary notes. Here's what they tell us

Other Distraction techniques

Check an article for whataboutism and 22 other techniques.

Analyze a URL